What to check before you approve.
Put the original beside the edited file and view both at 100% zoom. That means one image pixel for each screen pixel. Then check these eight things against the brief you agreed.
Agree what you need
Before editing starts, confirm the background, crop, dimensions, filename and whether you want a shadow.
A reference image helps everyone understand the finish you want.Check nothing has been lost
Compare the edit with the original. Look at straps, handles, corners, labels and any small parts that could have been cut away.
If a detail is missing, ask for a correction before approving.Look at the edges
View the cutout on white, grey and dark backgrounds. Look for pale outlines, dark fringes or bits of the old background.
An edge that looks fine on white may look very different on dark grey.Keep the material looking natural
Hair, fur and frayed fabric need softer edges than a cardboard box. Glass should still look transparent where it was transparent in the original.
Check that the edit still looks like the product you photographed.Make sure the shadow makes sense
Check the shadow against the brief. Look at where it meets the product, which way it falls and how dark it is.
If you want a different shadow, agree that treatment before work starts.Open the file you will actually use
Check the delivered file’s format, size, colour profile and transparency. Then look at the batch together to compare margins, scale and alignment.
Do this in the final files, rather than relying on a small preview.Say exactly what needs fixing
Give the filename, point out the area and explain what you want changed. Mention whether the problem is in the edit or already in the original.
For example: BAG-042_front.png, inside the left handle: please remove the remaining grey background.Keep track of the final version
Mark each file as approved, needing a correction or waiting for an answer. Record who checked it, and check corrected files again.
If you only review a sample, keep a note of which images have not been checked.