Inspect the source before choosing a treatment
Check product identity, packaging version, available views, clipping, focus and usable detail at the intended output size. Assign each source a route: ready to edit, waiting for a reference or unsuitable for the planned use. Record the reason in terms a supplier can act on.
A photograph with dust is different from one with a missing handle. Dust may be removable without changing construction. A missing handle needs reliable evidence or another photograph. Upscaling or sharpening cannot establish product details that were never recorded.
Standardise by category and view
Choose a small set of profiles for product families rather than forcing every shape into one occupancy rule. A tall bottle and a wide chair can share a square canvas without filling it in the same way. State whether margins are measured around the full object, including loose straps, or another clearly defined boundary.
Review front, side and detail views as a set. Align backgrounds and general presentation while preserving the perspective that the source actually supports. Aggressive warping can make two images appear consistent by changing their proportions, which is a poor trade for a product catalogue.
Do not imply a size comparison you cannot support
Separate product tiles often scale different objects to fill similar space. That is a framing choice, not evidence that the products have similar physical dimensions. If relative scale matters, provide verified measurements or a deliberately prepared comparison image with an explained basis.
Hypothetical example: two supplier chair photographs show different camera angles. One can meet the catalogue crop after background cleanup; the other hides the rear leg. Matching the second chair’s outline by reconstruction would introduce uncertainty. Flag the missing angle and request a compatible source instead.
Return specific feedback to suppliers
Keep an exception log with supplier, product key, affected view, problem and requested next action. “Please improve photography” is less useful than “the pump top is cropped; supply an uncropped front view of this packaging version”. Attach a marked thumbnail where it clarifies the request.
At the end of a batch, group recurring issues into a short capture guide. Include an accepted source example, a rejected example and the reason for the distinction. This reduces repeated corrections in later submissions. Track usable-source rate separately from editing quality so an intake problem does not disappear inside a retouching score.
